I don't know about that. It is subjective, but even Bruce Kulick who recorded with the band from Asylum to COS (and mostly on Psycho Circus-which I still think is a damn shame that it wasn't Ace) and he said as a perfectionist Revenge scored a 9/10 and that album was the tightest they've been in years. So they can be judged on technical merit.
But I'll re-phrase. What's the fave from 78-09? I'll use the consensus. Thanks for the input.

-O.K, let's take a call. You're on KISS Forum.
-KISS RULES!!!!  Whoooo!
-O.K. Good call. Good call.